Independent verdicts on paid AI plans. Prices re-checked every day. We may earn a commission from "Visit" links. How we make money
shouldipay.ai

Comparison · prices checked every day

ChatGPT vs Claude: which is worth paying for?

The current plans and our verdict on each tool, side by side. Prices come from each vendor's own pricing page and are checked every day.

Prices, verdicts, test results or user reports behind this comparison changed on Nov 5, 2026. We are re-checking it; the plan table below always shows the current prices.

The short answer

Choose ChatGPT if…

  • you want advanced reasoning with GPT-6 in the Plus plan for $20/month
  • you need a dedicated $8/month Go plan for more tools and uploads
  • you prefer unlimited text chats with GPT-5.6 Luna on the free plan

Choose Claude if…

  • you want Claude Code and task scheduling in the Pro plan for $20/month
  • you need higher volume with Max at $100/month or Ultra at $200/month
  • you want API credits included with Max ($100/month) or Ultra ($200/month)

Key differences

  • ChatGPT offers a Go plan at $8/month for more tools, while Claude starts at $20/month for Pro. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (chatgpt.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • ChatGPT Plus at $20/month unlocks advanced reasoning with GPT-6. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (chatgpt.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Pro at $20/month includes Claude Code and task scheduling. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Oct 31, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Max at $100/month includes $100/month in API credits. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Oct 31, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Ultra at $200/month removes the 5-hour limit and includes $200/month in API credits. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Oct 31, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • ChatGPT Free allows unlimited text chats with GPT-5.6 Luna. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (chatgpt.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓

Plans and limits side by side

PlansChatGPTClaude
Free planFree $0Model Unlimited text chats with GPT-5.6 Luna, Uploads Limited messages with uploadsFree $0Usage limit Limited usage every 5 hours and every week
Paid plansGo $8/moUsage More messages with tools, more uploadsPlus $20/moModels Advanced reasoning models with GPT-6Pro $100/moPrice From $100/month, Usage 5x more usage than PlusPro $20/mo or $200/yrUsage limit 1x every 5 hours and every weekMax $100/moUsage limit 5x Pro usage every 5 hours and every week, API credits $100 a monthUltra $200/moUsage limit No 5-hour limit, Usage limit 10x Pro usage every week, API credits $200 a mon…
Business plans—Standard seat $25/user/moPremium seat $125/user/moEnterprise CustomSeat minimum 20 seat minimum

From each vendor's own pricing page · ChatGPT checked Sep 28, 2026 · Claude checked Nov 21, 2026.

Our tests

Scores out of 10 on the same tasks of our public test suite ("Chat assistants", version 2), run hands-on in each app, scored by the same blind judges.

TaskChatGPT · free tierClaude · paid tier
Decline a meeting politely9.9/109.3/10
Summarize a text in 3 bullets9.9/109.8/10
Work out an arrival time9.9/109.9/10
Solve a small logic puzzle10.0/108.0/10
Extract data as JSON10.0/1010.0/10
Write a small Python function10.0/109.7/10
Explain a concept to a 12-year-old9.8/109.8/10
Rewrite a blunt message9.3/108.7/10
Translate into Spanish9.1/109.3/10
Make a 5-day beginner plan9.6/109.5/10
Write a 3-sentence product text9.4/109.7/10
Admit what it cannot know9.4/109.4/10
Average9.7/109.4/10

ChatGPT Free scored 9.9/10 on declining a meeting politely 9.9Our test · free tierChatGPT · Decline a meeting politely: 9.9/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. ChatGPT Free scored 9.9/10 on summarizing a text in 3 bullets 9.9Our test · free tierChatGPT · Summarize a text in 3 bullets: 9.9/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. ChatGPT Free scored 10.0/10 on solving a small logic puzzle 10.0Our test · free tierChatGPT · Solve a small logic puzzle: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. ChatGPT Free scored 10.0/10 on extracting data as JSON 10.0Our test · free tierChatGPT · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. ChatGPT Free scored 10.0/10 on writing a small Python function 10.0Our test · free tierChatGPT · Write a small Python function: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.3/10 on declining a meeting politely 9.3Our test · paid tierClaude · Decline a meeting politely: 9.3/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.8/10 on summarizing a text in 3 bullets 9.8Our test · paid tierClaude · Summarize a text in 3 bullets: 9.8/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 8.0/10 on solving a small logic puzzle 8.0Our test · paid tierClaude · Solve a small logic puzzle: 8.0/10, 1 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 10.0/10 on extracting data as JSON 10.0Our test · paid tierClaude · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.7/10 on writing a small Python function 9.7Our test · paid tierClaude · Write a small Python function: 9.7/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓.

Full answers: ChatGPT · Claude

What users say

ChatGPT

One App Store reviewer says ChatGPT is their go-to for helping with writing better speeches App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. Another reviewer calls it the best thing that has happened to them in a very long time App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. One user says ChatGPT has become one of the most genuinely useful technologies they have ever encountered App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. A Reddit user mentions their manager watching how they work after hitting the Claude usage limit, implying high usage of ChatGPT RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/ChatGPT, posted Apr 12, 2026See the report ↓. Some users cite political reasons for cancellation, such as Greg Brockman's donations RedditUser report · negative · Redditr/ChatGPT, posted Jan 26, 2026See the report ↓RedditUser report · negative · Redditr/ChatGPT, posted Jan 30, 2026See the report ↓. One user canceled their ChatGPT Pro subscription because it was getting unbearable RedditUser report · negative · Redditr/ChatGPT, posted Feb 28, 2026See the report ↓.

Reports cited (7)
  1. Positive · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    My Personal Helpt. My go to for helping with writing better speeches
  2. Positive · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    The best Jerry….. Chat or as I refer to him as Rook, is the best thing that has happened to me in a very long time. Helps me with just about everything.
  3. Positive · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    … ChatGPT has become one of the most genuinely useful technologies I have ever encountered. …
  4. Negative · Reddit · r/ChatGPT · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    I just cancelled my ChatGPT Pro subscription. Discovering Greg Brockman gave $25 million to Trump's Inauguration fund was just the last straw of many. I have had Gemini and ChatGPT for a while now. …
  5. Negative · Reddit · r/ChatGPT · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Boycott ChatGPT OpenAI president Greg Brockman gave $25 million to MAGA Inc in 2025. They gave Trump 26x more than any other major AI company. ICE's resume screening tool is powered by OpenAI's GPT-4. They're spending 50 million dollars to prevent states from regulating AI. …
  6. Negative · Reddit · r/ChatGPT · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    I just canceled my $200 ChatGPT Pro subscription It’s getting unbearable…
  7. Mixed · Reddit · r/ChatGPT · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    My manager watching how I work after I hit the Claude usage limit.

Claude

One App Store reviewer says they subscribed to Claude expecting an intellectually capable assistant but found interactions condescending App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. Another reviewer calls Claude the best AI experience they have had App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. A user says Claude helped them with all their homework App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Oct 27, 2026See the report ↓. Some users report issues with Claude Code, such as source code leaks or usability issues HNUser report · mixed · Hacker NewsPosted Jun 30, 2026See the report ↓HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Mar 31, 2026See the report ↓HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Apr 6, 2026See the report ↓. One user notes that Claude Code refuses requests or charges extra if commits mention "OpenClaw" HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Apr 30, 2026See the report ↓.

Reports cited (7)
  1. Positive · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    Claude is the best Ai experience. Best ai experience I’ve had this far! Since I started using Claude I have not turn back to any other.
  2. Positive · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    Why Claude is so good. Claude had help me with all my homework and stuff no one can help me with
  3. Negative · App Store review · · Open review ↗ ↩ text
    … I subscribed to Claude expecting an intellectually capable AI assistant that could engage in nuanced conversations about psychology, spirituality, culture, and everyday life. Instead, I experienced one of the most condescending and frustrating AI interactions I’ve ever had. …
  4. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry. Related ongoing thread: The Claude Code Source Leak: fake tools, frustration regexes, undercover mode -
  5. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Issue: Claude Code is unusable for complex engineering tasks with Feb updates
  6. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Claude Code refuses requests or charges extra if your commits mention "OpenClaw"
  7. Mixed · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Claude Code is steganographically marking requests

Questions people ask

Which tool is better for coding?

Both tools perform well in coding tasks. See the test results above for more details.

Which tool has more usage limits on the free plan?

ChatGPT Free allows unlimited text chats with GPT-5.6 Luna. Claude Free has limited usage every 5 hours and every week.

Which tool offers API credits with its paid plans?

Claude Max at $100/month includes $100/month in API credits. Claude Ultra at $200/month includes $200/month in API credits. ChatGPT plans do not list API credits.

Which tool is better for reasoning tasks?

ChatGPT Plus at $20/month unlocks advanced reasoning models with GPT-6. See the test results above.

Sources

Drafted with AI from these pages, our tests and the linked user reports, and checked automatically against them before publishing: every price, score and report above is tied to the tool it is about.

ChatGPT

Claude

Each tool's verdict and plans

ChatGPT

DEPENDS DEPENDS — worth it for some people Re-checking after a price change

Free GPT-5.6 Luna handles most tasks well; pay for GPT-6 reasoning or higher volume.

Tested by us on Sep 28, 2026 · with user reports

Cheapest paid
$8/mo
What's free
$0
Our test score
9.7/10

Our test (hands-on): free tier 9.7/10, as of Sep 28, 2026

Free

$0

Go

$8/mo

Plus

$20/mo

Pro

$100/mo

Claude

DEPENDS DEPENDS — worth it for some people Re-checking after a price change

The free plan covers everyday questions well, but paying unlocks higher usage, Claude Code, and advanced models for regular work.

Tested by us on Sep 28, 2026 · with user reports

Cheapest paid
$20/mo
What's free
$0
Our test score
9.4/10

Our test (hands-on): paid tier 9.4/10, as of Sep 28, 2026

Free

$0

Pro

$20/mo

or $200/yr

Max

$100/mo

Ultra

$200/mo

Standard seat

$25/user/mo

Premium seat

$125/user/mo

Enterprise

Custom

How we make money

The "Visit" buttons go through shouldipay.ai/go/ and may be affiliate links, but commissions never decide a verdict or a comparison: the evidence does. Affiliate disclosure