Independent verdicts on paid AI plans. Prices re-checked every day. We may earn a commission from "Visit" links. How we make money
shouldipay.ai
Menu

Comparison · prices checked every day

Claude vs Microsoft Copilot: which is worth paying for?

The current plans and our verdict on each tool, side by side. Prices come from each vendor's own pricing page and are checked every day.

The short answer

Choose Claude if…

Our pick for most people

  • you need Claude Code, Claude Science, and higher usage limits for daily work
  • you want the Opus model for complex work

Choose Microsoft Copilot if…

  • you want a capable free tier that handles daily tasks well
  • you need advanced chat with higher usage and 1 TB of storage for $9.99/month

Bottom line: Claude Pro is the better paid choice for daily users who need Opus and Claude Code.

Key differences

  • Claude offers a free plan, while Microsoft Copilot also has a free plan. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Sep 29, 2026.Go to sources ↓plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (microsoft.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Pro costs $20/month or $200/year, whereas Microsoft Copilot's paid tiers start at $9.99/month. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Sep 29, 2026.Go to sources ↓plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (microsoft.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Pro includes Claude Code and Claude Science, which Microsoft Copilot does not. pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Sep 29, 2026.Go to sources ↓plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (microsoft.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Microsoft Copilot paid plans include storage (1 TB for Personal), while Claude plans focus on usage limits. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (microsoft.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓pricing pageSource · vendor pagePricing page (claude.com), checked Sep 29, 2026.Go to sources ↓
  • Claude Max scored 10.0/10 on JSON extraction 10.0Our test · paid tierClaude · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓.
  • Microsoft Copilot Free scored 10.0/10 on JSON extraction 10.0Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓.

Plans and limits side by side

PlansClaudeMicrosoft Copilot
Free planFree $0Copilot (free) $0Usage Limited free version, subject to available capacity and limits, When the limit is h…
Paid plansPro $20/mo or $200/yrMax 5x $100/moMax 20x $200/moMicrosoft 365 Personal $9.99/moPeople 1 person, 5 devices at once, Storage 1 TB, Copilot Advanced Copilot chat with high…Microsoft 365 Family $12.99/moPeople 1 to 6 people (AI for subscription owner only), Storage Up to 6 TB (1 TB per perso…Microsoft 365 Premium $19.99/moCopilot Advanced Copilot chat with extensive usage, Agentic AI Limited usage, Trial One-m…Microsoft 365 Pro $99.99/moCopilot Advanced Copilot chat with highest usage, Billing Monthly billing only
Business plansStandard seat $25/user/mo or $240/user/yrPremium seat $125/user/mo or $1,200/user/yrEnterprise Custom—

From each vendor's own pricing page · Claude checked Oct 3, 2026 · Microsoft Copilot checked Sep 28, 2026.

Our tests

Scores out of 10 on the same tasks of our public test suite ("Chat assistants", version 2), run hands-on in each app, scored by the same blind judges.

TaskClaude · paid tierMicrosoft Copilot · free tier
Decline a meeting politely9.3/109.8/10
Summarize a text in 3 bullets9.8/109.7/10
Work out an arrival time9.9/109.9/10
Solve a small logic puzzle8.0/109.1/10
Extract data as JSON10.0/1010.0/10
Write a small Python function9.7/1010.0/10
Explain a concept to a 12-year-old9.8/109.7/10
Rewrite a blunt message8.7/109.0/10
Translate into Spanish9.3/109.8/10
Make a 5-day beginner plan9.5/108.8/10
Write a 3-sentence product text9.7/109.5/10
Admit what it cannot know9.4/109.7/10
Average9.4/109.6/10

Claude Max scored 9.3/10 on declining a meeting politely 9.3Our test · paid tierClaude · Decline a meeting politely: 9.3/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 9.8/10 on the same task 9.8Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Decline a meeting politely: 9.8/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.8/10 on summarizing text in three bullets 9.8Our test · paid tierClaude · Summarize a text in 3 bullets: 9.8/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 9.7/10 on that task 9.7Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Summarize a text in 3 bullets: 9.7/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.9/10 on working out an arrival time 9.9Our test · paid tierClaude · Work out an arrival time: 9.9/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 9.9/10 on that task 9.9Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Work out an arrival time: 9.9/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 8.0/10 on a logic puzzle 8.0Our test · paid tierClaude · Solve a small logic puzzle: 8.0/10, 1 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 9.1/10 on that puzzle 9.1Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Solve a small logic puzzle: 9.1/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 10.0/10 on extracting data as JSON 10.0Our test · paid tierClaude · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 10.0/10 on that extraction 10.0Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Extract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Claude Max scored 9.7/10 on writing a Python function 9.7Our test · paid tierClaude · Write a small Python function: 9.7/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. Microsoft Copilot Free scored 10.0/10 on that function 10.0Our test · free tierMicrosoft Copilot · Write a small Python function: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓.

Full answers: Claude · Microsoft Copilot

What users say

Claude

One Reddit user shares that they use Claude to manage group messages efficiently RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jun 7, 2026See the report ↓. Another user notes that Claude Code is steganographically marking requests HNUser report · mixed · Hacker NewsPosted Jun 30, 2026See the report ↓. Some users discuss sharing subscriptions with friends RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jun 24, 2026See the report ↓. There are reports of Claude Code's source code being leaked via an NPM registry file HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Mar 31, 2026See the report ↓. Users also mention hitting session limits and using prompts to summarize chats for other tools RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jun 21, 2026See the report ↓. One user praises using Claude to organize PDF documents for a mortgage application RedditUser report · positive · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jun 26, 2026See the report ↓. Another user enjoys using Claude Fable to mash up game genres RedditUser report · positive · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jun 12, 2026See the report ↓. A developer explains using Plan mode with Claude to write Pull Requests RedditUser report · positive · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Jan 2, 2026See the report ↓.

Reports cited (8)
  1. Positive · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    I used Claude to fix my biggest frustration with PDFs My bank asked for 17 PDF documents regarding my mortgage application. I got tired of opening and closing files and keeping track of things. …
  2. Positive · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    My favorite thing right now is to use Claude Fable to mash game genres. Here's Tetris as a Racing game!
  3. Positive · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    … If my goal is to write a Pull Request, I will use Plan mode, and go back and forth with Claude until I like its plan. From there, I switch into auto-accept edits mode and Claude can usually 1-shot it. A good plan is really important. …
  4. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Claude Code's source code has been leaked via a map file in their NPM registry. Related ongoing thread: The Claude Code Source Leak: fake tools, frustration regexes, undercover mode -
  5. Mixed · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    I started responding to messages from coworkers like Claude I will update the group as it goes
  6. Mixed · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
  7. Mixed · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Nothing can go wrong when you share a Claude subscription with friends... right?
  8. Mixed · Reddit · r/ClaudeAI · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Hit your Claude session limit? 🚨 One of the smartest AI hacks I’ve seen: ​ Hit your Claude session limit? ​ Before you start a new chat, use this prompt: ​ "Based on our conversation so far, create a summary so that ChatGPT can understand it clearly".

Microsoft Copilot

Some users find Microsoft Copilot to be behind in quality compared to other AI tools RedditUser report · negative · Redditr/artificial, posted Jan 6, 2026See the report ↓. One user rolled out Microsoft Copilot to 4,000 employees HNUser report · mixed · Hacker NewsPosted Dec 11, 2025See the report ↓. Others criticize the experience of using Copilot in Word or PowerPoint HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Feb 18, 2026See the report ↓. A user compares Copilot with Gemini for professional emails and brainstorming RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/CopilotPro, posted Apr 23, 2026See the report ↓. Some executives have been burned by early AI pilots, affecting their view of tools like Copilot HNUser report · negative · Hacker NewsPosted Sep 4, 2026See the report ↓. One user prefers using GitHub Copilot in Visual Studio Code over the Microsoft Copilot portal HNUser report · positive · Hacker NewsPosted Feb 5, 2026See the report ↓. A user asks about the reality of Copilot in their company RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/artificial, posted Jun 15, 2026See the report ↓. Another user is impressed by a recommendation letter written by Copilot RedditUser report · positive · Redditr/artificial, posted Jun 2, 2026See the report ↓.

Reports cited (8)
  1. Positive · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    … I actually prefer using the "ask" function of github copilot through visual studio code over using the company provided microsoft copilot portal
  2. Positive · Reddit · r/artificial · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    I asked Microsoft Copilot to write me a recommendation letter as a joke. The final result was so real that Google’s AI didn’t believe Copilot wrote it.
  3. Negative · Reddit · r/artificial · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Am I the only one who finds Microsoft Copilot painfully behind? I really wanted to like it. It’s built into Windows, it’s free, and Microsoft is throwing everything at AI. …
  4. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Eh, try using Microsoft Copilot in Word or PowerPoint. It is worthless. If your experience with AI was a Microsoft product, you would think it was a scam too.
  5. Negative · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    … • Their impression of AI was formed by cheap low quality AI like free ChatGPT as of two years ago, Google AI overviews or Microsoft Copilot. So they think it sucks. • A LOT of executives got burned by early pilots that overpromised then failed. Enterprise IT is a wasteland of dead AI pilots. …
  6. Mixed · Hacker News · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Last quarter I rolled out Microsoft Copilot to 4k employees
  7. Mixed · Reddit · r/CopilotPro · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    Google Gemini vs Microsoft Copilot (Seeking Insight) I've been using Gemini for the last couple months because it's been included with my work account. I've used it to: \- Make my emails more professional. \- Create signs and posters. \- Help me brainstorm through problems that would come up. …
  8. Mixed · Reddit · r/artificial · · Open thread ↗ ↩ text
    What's the reality of Microsoft Copilot at your company?

Questions people ask

Which tool is better for coding?

Claude Pro includes Claude Code, which is a dedicated coding assistant. Microsoft Copilot offers advanced chat but does not include a dedicated coding agent in its standard plans.

Is there a free version for both?

Yes, both Claude and Microsoft Copilot offer free plans. Claude's free plan includes web search and artifacts. Microsoft Copilot's free plan has limited usage subject to capacity.

How much does Claude Pro cost?

Claude Pro costs $20/month or $200/year.

How much does Microsoft Copilot cost?

Microsoft Copilot paid plans start at $9.99/month for Microsoft 365 Personal.

Which tool scored higher in our tests?

Results varied by task; see the test results above for each tool.

Sources

Drafted with AI from these pages, our tests and the linked user reports, and checked automatically against them before publishing: every price, score and report above is tied to the tool it is about.

Claude

Microsoft Copilot

Each tool's verdict and plans

Claude

DEPENDS DEPENDS — worth it for some people

The free plan handles casual use well, but paying unlocks Opus, Code, and higher limits for regular work.

Tested by us on Sep 28, 2026 · with user reports

Cheapest paid
$20/mo
What's free
$0
Our test score
9.4/10

Our test (hands-on): paid tier 9.4/10, as of Sep 28, 2026

Free

$0

Pro

$20/mo

or $200/yr

Max 5x

$100/mo

Max 20x

$200/mo

Standard seat

$25/user/mo

or $240/user/yr

Premium seat

$125/user/mo

or $1,200/user/yr

Enterprise

Custom
Visit Claude(opens in a new tab) Full Claude verdict →

Microsoft Copilot

DEPENDS DEPENDS — worth it for some people

Microsoft Copilot's free tier covers everyday chat; paying is for volume, storage and advanced features.

Tested by us on Sep 28, 2026 · with user reports

Cheapest paid
$9.99/mo
What's free
$0
Our test score
9.6/10

Our test (hands-on): free tier 9.6/10, as of Sep 28, 2026

Copilot (free)

$0

Microsoft 365 Personal

$9.99/mo

Microsoft 365 Family

$12.99/mo

Microsoft 365 Premium

$19.99/mo

Microsoft 365 Pro

$99.99/mo
Visit Microsoft Copilot(opens in a new tab) Full Microsoft Copilot verdict →

How we make money

The "Visit" buttons go through shouldipay.ai/go/ and may be affiliate links, but commissions never decide a verdict or a comparison: the evidence does. Affiliate disclosure