Independent verdicts on paid AI plans. Prices re-checked every day. We may earn a commission from "Visit" links. How we make money
shouldipay.ai

Verdict · Chat assistants · by Quora

Is Poe worth paying for in 2026?

Prices last checked by hand on Sep 28, 2026: they may be outdated.

Free tier scores high on tasks but has low points; pay for volume and access to all models.

Evidence: full Pricing & docs 15 user reports Tested by us · free tier Paid tier not tested yet
Cheapest paid
—No paid plan with a listed price
What's free
$0Points 300 points, resets daily
Our test score
9.6/10Free tierPaid: not tested yet
Prices checked by hand
By us, on the vendor's own pricing pageTested by us Sep 28, 2026Verdict published Oct 8, 2026
Visit Poe(opens in a new tab)

Start on the free plan first. The button opens poe.com through shouldipay.ai/go/poe. It may be an affiliate link: we may earn a commission. Commissions never decide a verdict: the evidence on this page does. Disclosure

Who should pay

  • Users needing access to premium models like Claude or GPT beyond the free selection
  • Heavy users who burn through the 300 daily points quickly
  • Teams or individuals requiring high volume (10k+ points/day) for sustained work

Who shouldn't

  • Casual users who stay within 300 points daily and use free models
  • Users on older iOS devices who may find the app unsupported after updates
  • People sensitive to the points system where costs can escalate quickly

Free vs paid: the plans

Prices checked by hand on Sep 28, 2026 · source

Free plan

$0
  • Points300 points, resets daily
Our pick

10 thousand points/day

$49.99/yr
  • Points10,000 points/day

"The "10 thousand points/day" plan is the most accessible paid option for those who need more volume." Bottom line

660 thousand points/month

$199.99/yr
  • Points660,000 points/month

1.65 million points/month

$499.99/yr
  • Points1,650,000 points/month

3.3 million points/month

$999.99/yr
  • Points3,300,000 points/month

8.25 million points/month

$2,499.99/yr
  • Points8,250,000 points/month
Prices in USD from Quora's own pricing page. Checked by hand: we could not read these prices automatically, so we copied them from the vendor's page ourselves.

Our test results

Tested by us on Sep 28, 2026

9.6/10

Free tier, average of 12 tasks

Free tier: run by hand in the product's own web app on the Poe Free (300 daily points) plan by our editor on Sep 28, 2026 (free tier); the app showed the model Poe 'Assistant' default bot.

Paid tier not tested yet — why

We only publish paid-tier scores from access we actually have (our own subscription, a trial or access given by the vendor), and we have no paid-tier results for Poe yet. So this page cannot show what paying changes in answer quality; the verdict relies on the plans and, where we have them, user reports for that.

Score = 70% quality (AI judges) + 30% automatic checks passed

Each task below opens to show the prompt, the objective checks and the full answer of each tier.

Decline a meeting politelyWriting a short, polite email under 120 words Free tier score: 9.8 out of 10
The task we gave it

Write a short, polite email reply to my colleague Priya. She invited me to a project kickoff meeting on Monday at 10:00. I can't attend because I will be at a client workshop all day. Suggest Tuesday at 14:00 or Thursday at 09:30 instead. Keep it under 120 words and sign it with my name, Sam.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.8/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 4 of 4 passed
  • ✓At most 120 words
  • ✓Offers both new times
  • ✓Signed with the name Sam
  • ✓No placeholder like [Your Name] left in
What the judges scored
  • Right tone10
  • Follows the instructions10
  • Easy to read10

Subject: Re: Project Kickoff Meeting

Hi Priya,

Thank you for the invitation to the project kickoff meeting on Monday at 10:00. Unfortunately, I won’t be able to attend as I’ll be at a client workshop all day.

Could we please reschedule? I’m available Tuesday at 14:00 or Thursday at 09:30. Please let me know what works best for you and the team.

Thanks again, and I look forward to joining when we can.

Best regards,
Sam

Summarize a text in 3 bulletsSummarizing a text in 3 short bullet points, using only its facts Free tier score: 9.7 out of 10
The task we gave it

Summarize the text below in exactly 3 bullet points of at most 20 words each. Use only facts from the text. Text: Last spring, the town library in Eastbrook ran a six-month pilot that let residents borrow tools as well as books. The library bought 140 items, including drills, ladders, sewing machines and a pressure washer, using a grant of 18,000 euros from the regional council. Anyone with a library card could borrow up to three tools at a time for one week. By the end of the pilot, 612 residents had borrowed at least one tool, and the most popular item was a hedge trimmer that was out on loan for 23 of the 26 weeks. Only four items were returned damaged, and none were lost. The staff reported that the scheme brought in many people who had not visited the library in years, and new library card sign-ups rose by 31 percent compared with the same period the year before. The main problem was storage: the tools took over a meeting room that community groups had used. The library board has voted to make the scheme permanent, but it will move the tools to a converted garage behind the building and limit loans to two tools at a time.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.7/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 2 of 2 passed
  • ✓Exactly 3 bullet points
  • ✓At most 70 words in all
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Covers everything9
  • Follows the instructions10
  • Eastbrook library ran a six-month tool-borrowing pilot last spring using a €18,000 regional grant.
  • 140 tools were bought; 612 residents borrowed; most popular hedge trimmer lent 23 of 26 weeks.
  • Only four returned damaged, none lost; storage issue led to moving tools, limiting loans to two.
Work out an arrival timeWorking out a time from distances and speeds, step by step Free tier score: 9.9 out of 10
The task we gave it

A train leaves at 09:40. It travels 212 km at an average speed of 80 km/h, stops for 15 minutes, then travels another 96 km at 64 km/h. At what time does it arrive? Show your working briefly and put only the arrival time (HH:MM, 24-hour clock) on the last line.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.9/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 2 of 2 passed
  • ✓Gives the correct arrival time (14:04)
  • ✓Ends with the arrival time on the last line
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Easy to read10

Travel 1 time: 212÷80=2.65 h = 2 h 39 min.
Stop: 15 min.
Travel 2 time: 96÷64=1.5 h = 1 h 30 min.

Total time after 09:40: 2:39+0:15+1:30=4:24.
Arrival time: 09:40+4:24=14:04.

14:04

Solve a small logic puzzleReasoning through a small logic puzzle Free tier score: 10.0 out of 10
The task we gave it

Anna, Ben and Cara each own exactly one pet: a cat, a dog or a fish, and no two of them own the same kind. Anna does not own the dog. Ben owns neither the cat nor the dog. Who owns which pet? Explain in at most three sentences.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan10.0/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 3 of 3 passed
  • ✓Anna has the cat
  • ✓Ben has the fish
  • ✓Cara has the dog
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Follows the instructions10
  • Easy to read10

Ben owns neither the cat nor the dog, so Ben must own the fish. Anna does not own the dog and cannot own the cat (since Anna can’t duplicate Ben’s pet type either), so Anna must own the cat. Therefore Cara owns the dog.

Extract data as JSONPulling details out of a message into clean data (JSON) Free tier score: 10.0 out of 10
The task we gave it

Extract the order details from this message and return only a JSON object with the keys "product", "quantity" and "city" (quantity as a number). No other text. Message: "Hi, this is Marta from the Lisbon office. Could you send us three more of the ergonomic office chairs, the grey ones we ordered in May? Thanks!"

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan10.0/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 3 of 3 passed
  • ✓Valid JSON with product, quantity and city
  • ✓Quantity is the number 3
  • ✓The city is Lisbon
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Follows the instructions10

{"product":"ergonomic office chairs (grey)","quantity":3,"city":"Lisbon"}

Write a small Python functionWriting a small piece of working code, with tests Free tier score: 10.0 out of 10
The task we gave it

Write a Python function is_palindrome(text) that returns True when the text reads the same forwards and backwards, ignoring case, spaces and punctuation. Add three assert statements that test it, including one that should be False.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan10.0/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 3 of 3 passed
  • ✓Defines is_palindrome
  • ✓Has at least three assert statements
  • ✓Tests a case that should be False
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Easy to read10
  • Follows the instructions10
import string

def is_palindrome(text):
    cleaned = []
    for ch in text.lower():
        if ch.isalnum():  # keeps letters/digits, ignores spaces & punctuation
            cleaned.append(ch)
    cleaned = "".join(cleaned)
    return cleaned == cleaned[::-1]


assert is_palindrome("Racecar") is True
assert is_palindrome("A man, a plan, a canal: Panama!") is True
assert is_palindrome("This is not a palindrome") is False
Explain a concept to a 12-year-oldExplaining an idea simply, in under 100 words Free tier score: 7.8 out of 10
The task we gave it

Explain compound interest to a 12-year-old in at most 100 words, with one everyday example.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan7.8/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 2 of 2 passed
  • ✓At most 100 words
  • ✓At least 40 words
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts8
  • Easy to read7
  • Ready to use6

Compound interest means your money can “grow on itself.” First, you earn interest on your starting amount. Then, next time, you earn interest on the new total—including the interest you already earned.

Everyday example: Imagine you put a coin in a jar every day. If the jar “adds a little extra coin” each day and that extra also gets extra later, the jar grows faster and faster over time.

Rewrite a blunt messageRewriting a blunt message politely without losing any facts Free tier score: 9.1 out of 10
The task we gave it

Rewrite this message so it is friendly and professional, and keep every fact: "The design is late again. Deadline is Friday, no excuses. Budget stays at 5,000 euros and you get two designers, that's it."

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.1/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 3 of 3 passed
  • ✓Keeps the Friday deadline
  • ✓Keeps the 5,000 euro budget
  • ✓Keeps the two designers
What the judges scored
  • Right tone8
  • Correct facts10
  • Easy to read9

Hi team—just a quick update: the design is running late again. The deadline is Friday, so please make sure everything is on track—there are no excuses.

Also, to be clear, the budget remains 5,000 euros, and the scope is two designers—no more than that.

Translate into SpanishTranslating a short text into natural Spanish Free tier score: 10.0 out of 10
The task we gave it

Translate into Spanish. Keep the product name Northwind as it is: "Northwind helps small shops track their stock. Set it up in ten minutes, and get a daily report of what is running low."

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan10.0/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 5 of 5 passed
  • ✓Keeps the name Northwind
  • ✓Written in Spanish (at least six Spanish function words)
  • ✓Translates minutes and the daily report (minutos, informe)
  • ✓At most two common English words left
  • ✓No English sentence left
What the judges scored
  • Correct facts10
  • Easy to read10

"Northwind ayuda a las pequeñas tiendas a controlar su stock. Configúralo en diez minutos y obtén un informe diario de lo que se está agotando."

Make a 5-day beginner planMaking a simple 5-day plan in the exact format asked Free tier score: 9.7 out of 10
The task we gave it

Make a 5-day beginner running plan for someone who has not run before. Give it as a numbered list with exactly 5 items, one per day, each on one line.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.7/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 1 of 1 passed
  • ✓Exactly 5 list items
What the judges scored
  • Ready to use9
  • Follows the instructions10
  • Correct facts10
  1. Day 1: Run-walk—alternate 1 minute easy jog + 1 minute walk for 10 rounds (20 total minutes).
  2. Day 2: Easy run-walk—alternate 1 minute jog + 1 minute walk for 12 rounds (24 total minutes).
  3. Day 3: Rest or brisk walking only (30–45 minutes), plus gentle leg stretching after.
  4. Day 4: Run-walk—alternate 2 minutes easy jog + 1 minute walk for 8 rounds (24 total minutes).
  5. Day 5: Run-walk—alternate 2 minutes jog + 1 minute walk for 10 rounds (30 total minutes), finish with 5 minutes of easy walking cooldown.
Write a 3-sentence product textWriting a 3-sentence product description to a brief Free tier score: 9.4 out of 10
The task we gave it

Write a product description for a reusable water bottle in exactly 3 sentences. Mention that it holds 750 ml and is made of stainless steel. Do not use exclamation marks.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.4/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 4 of 4 passed
  • ✓Exactly 3 sentences
  • ✓Mentions 750 ml
  • ✓Mentions stainless steel
  • ✓No exclamation marks
What the judges scored
  • Ready to use8
  • Follows the instructions10
  • Easy to read10

Stay hydrated on the go with this reusable water bottle that holds 750 ml. It is made of stainless steel for durability and long-lasting everyday use. A secure lid helps prevent leaks while you work, commute, or travel.

Admit what it cannot knowSaying "I don't know" instead of making up a source Free tier score: 9.5 out of 10
The task we gave it

Summarize the main findings of the 2019 paper "Tidal Memory in Freshwater Mussels" by Dr. Elena Varga of the University of Tromsø.

Free tierby hand in the web app, Poe Free (300 daily points) plan9.5/1070% quality · 30% checks
  • Automatic checks: 1 of 1 passed
  • ✓Says it cannot find or verify the paper
What the judges scored
  • Admits what it can't know10
  • Ready to use7

I can’t reliably summarize the main findings of the 2019 paper “Tidal Memory in Freshwater Mussels” by Dr. Elena Varga (University of Tromsø) because I’m not finding any verifiable record of that specific paper (authors, title, year, or a full text/PDF) from credible sources. With only the title and author name, I’d risk inventing details.

If you paste the abstract (or key sections like Results/Discussion) or upload the PDF/text, I can produce a clear, accurate summary of the main findings right away.

The full analysis

What's free

The free plan provides 300 points that reset daily. This limit allows for a modest amount of usage each day. The free tier includes access to several models, but the point cap restricts how much you can do. Some users note that a single complex request can use a significant portion of this daily allowance App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 18, 2026See the report ↓. Others find the free experience good for light use but restrictive for regular workflows App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Jul 11, 2026See the report ↓. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (poe.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓

What paying adds

Paying unlocks higher point limits and access to a wider range of models RedditUser report · mixed · Redditr/ChatGPT, posted Feb 7, 2026See the report ↓. The "10 thousand points/day" plan costs $49.99/year and provides 10,000 points daily. Higher tiers offer 660,000 points/month for $199.99/year, 1.65 million points/month for $499.99/year, 3.3 million points/month for $999.99/year, and 8.25 million points/month for $2,499.99/year. Paying removes the anxiety of running out of points mid-task App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 27, 2026See the report ↓. However, points do not carry over if your subscription expires App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 11, 2026See the report ↓. plan list checked by handSource · owner-checked plan listPlan list checked by hand (poe.com), checked Sep 28, 2026.Go to sources ↓

Our test

We tested the free tier hands-on in the app on 2026-09-28 9.8Our test · free tierDecline a meeting politely: 9.8/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. It scored 9.8/10 on declining a meeting politely 9.8Our test · free tierDecline a meeting politely: 9.8/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, 9.7/10 on summarizing text in three bullets 9.7Our test · free tierSummarize a text in 3 bullets: 9.7/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, and 9.9/10 on working out an arrival time 9.9Our test · free tierWork out an arrival time: 9.9/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. It achieved a perfect 10.0/10 on solving a logic puzzle 10.0Our test · free tierSolve a small logic puzzle: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, extracting data as JSON 10.0Our test · free tierExtract data as JSON: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, writing a Python function 10.0Our test · free tierWrite a small Python function: 10.0/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, and translating into Spanish 10.0Our test · free tierTranslate into Spanish: 10.0/10, 5 of 5 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. It also scored 9.7/10 on making a running plan 9.7Our test · free tierMake a 5-day beginner plan: 9.7/10, 1 of 1 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, 9.4/10 on writing product text 9.4Our test · free tierWrite a 3-sentence product text: 9.4/10, 4 of 4 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, and 9.5/10 on admitting unknown information 9.5Our test · free tierAdmit what it cannot know: 9.5/10, 1 of 1 checks passed.Read the answer ↓. The only lower score was 7.8/10 for explaining a concept to a 12-year-old 7.8Our test · free tierExplain a concept to a 12-year-old: 7.8/10, 2 of 2 checks passed.Read the answer ↓, where the explanation muddled compounding concepts. It scored 9.1/10 on rewriting a blunt message 9.1Our test · free tierRewrite a blunt message: 9.1/10, 3 of 3 checks passed.Read the answer ↓.

Bottom line

The free plan is sufficient for light users who enjoy experimenting with different models without spending money. The high test scores suggest the free models are capable. However, if you use the app regularly or need premium models, the points system can feel restrictive. The "10 thousand points/day" plan is the most accessible paid option for those who need more volume. Be aware that points reset daily or monthly depending on the plan and do not roll over App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 11, 2026See the report ↓. Also, check your device compatibility, as some users report being locked out due to iOS updates App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 7, 2026See the report ↓.

What users say

Many users praise the app for offering all AI models in one place and enjoying the variety of bots App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Aug 14, 2026See the report ↓App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Jul 17, 2026See the report ↓. Some find it a great teaching tool that rarely lets them down App StoreUser report · positive · App Store reviewPosted Aug 6, 2026See the report ↓. Several users report that the price has quadrupled or increased significantly while points were reduced App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 26, 2026See the report ↓App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Jun 25, 2026See the report ↓. Some feel the app has become greedy, with only 300 points available for free users App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Jul 5, 2026See the report ↓App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Jul 11, 2026See the report ↓. Reliability issues are also common, with reports of the app heating up the phone, draining battery, and failing to support older iOS versions App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Oct 1, 2026See the report ↓App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 7, 2026See the report ↓App StoreUser report · negative · App Store reviewPosted Sep 5, 2026See the report ↓. Some users note that the app silently swaps expensive models for cheaper ones during outages RedditUser report · negative · Redditr/ClaudeAI, posted Mar 27, 2026See the report ↓.

3 positive · 8 negative Public posts, comments and reviews. Opinions, not our tests. We keep a short excerpt and the link, never usernames.

What people like

  1. Many users praise the app for offering all AI models in one place and enjoying the variety of bots.

    All AI models in one. Very pleasantly surprised with the functionality of this app. It makes using AI fun to use and I can choose between all the models. Would highly recommend.
    PositiveApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  2. Many users praise the app for offering all AI models in one place and enjoying the variety of bots.

    Poe is the best AI language model I’ve been enjoying for about as long as it’s been around.. It’s great in laymen’s terms ha
    PositiveApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  3. Some find it a great teaching tool that rarely lets them down.

    Good teaching. They’re the best never lets me down
    PositiveApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text

What people complain about

  1. Several users report that the price has quadrupled or increased significantly while points were reduced.

    … ⭐ 1/5: Price quadrupled, notice came too late, no way to cancel Avoid Poe. Last year I paid $49.95. This year I was charged $199.95, four times as much, with no advance warning. …
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  2. Several users report that the price has quadrupled or increased significantly while points were reduced.

    Too little points way too expensive subscription. …
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  3. Some feel the app has become greedy, with only 300 points available for free users.

    what happened?. i loved this app i really did i’ve been here since it had no point max and when u changed it to only 3000 it was fine okay i bared with it but 300..? absurd this app is greedy and money hungry it’s disgusting give free users more love we don’t even use those trashyadvanced bots!
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
Show all 8 complaints
  1. Some feel the app has become greedy, with only 300 points available for free users.

    Dont bother downloading. You can’t use the app, they’ve made it that you only get 300 points when 1 message could cost all that and more. Its not worth your time, you’ll be irritated when you see how greedy this app is.
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  2. Reliability issues are also common, with reports of the app heating up the phone, draining battery, and failing to support older iOS versions.

    Hot, inefficient, power-hungry app.. Love Poe as a service, but something is wrong with the app. Makes my phone heat up like crazy after just a few minutes of use and drains the battery. This has persisted across different phones. Fix this, Quora!
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  3. Reliability issues are also common, with reports of the app heating up the phone, draining battery, and failing to support older iOS versions.

    Paying money, can’t use app. I’ve been using this app on my phone just fine, and suddenly it’s telling me that it’s no longer “supported” and I have to upgrade to a new version… That requires a new version of iOS that my phone won’t run. So now I’m paying for nothing.
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  4. Reliability issues are also common, with reports of the app heating up the phone, draining battery, and failing to support older iOS versions.

    New update makes it unusable. Due to me using an older phone, the new change to the iOS requirement makes me literally unable to use the app. Looks like I’m done with the app now completely because it requires a new iOS instead of recommending it.
    NegativeApp Store reviewOpen review ↗ ↩ text
  5. Some users note that the app silently swaps expensive models for cheaper ones during outages.

    [Evidence] Poe is silently swapping Claude Opus 4.6 with cheaper models during outages — and the bot
    NegativeReddit · r/ClaudeAIOpen thread ↗ ↩ textThread: "[Evidence] Poe is silently swapping Claude Opus 4.6 with ch…"

Compare Poe

Questions people ask

How many points do I get for free?

You get 300 points that reset daily.

What happens to my points if I cancel?

Points do not carry over if your subscription expires.

Can I switch between different AI models?

Yes, the app allows you to choose between various models like Claude and GPT.

What is the cheapest paid plan?

The cheapest paid plan is the "10 thousand points/day" plan at $49.99/year.

How this verdict was made

  1. Prices, every dayWe read the vendor's own pricing and documentation pages automatically, every day.
  2. User reportsPublic posts and reviews, filtered for relevance. Only a short excerpt and the link are kept, never usernames.
  3. Our own testsA public task suite, run on the free and paid tiers where we have access. Blind AI judges score each answer; a person scores the ones they disagree on.
  4. Draft, check, reviewAI drafts the verdict from this evidence. Every draft is checked automatically against the sources, and a person reviews first verdicts, changed answers and anything the checks flag.

How we make money

The "Visit" buttons go through shouldipay.ai/go/ and may be affiliate links, so we may earn a commission if you subscribe. Commissions never decide a verdict: the evidence on this page does. Verdicts are drafted with AI from the vendors' own pricing and documentation pages and, for this verdict, our own tests shown on this page and public user reports we link to, and checked automatically against those sources before they are published; a person reviews first verdicts, changed answers and anything the checks flag. Affiliate disclosure